Giant or Orbea - Cycling Mob: Road Cycling, Mountain Biking and More

12-12-2003, 07:28 AM

Hi there, hoping you might be able to help. I'm looking at two bikes:
a 2004 Giant TCR (not the composite model), and a 2004 Orbea
Marmolada. Does anyone have any experience with any of these bikes
(including older version!) - or these brands?

I can't find any reviews of the Orbea (they're all in Spanish), so any
comments would be appreciated.

Thanks.

Reenie

12-12-2003, 10:06 AM

>Hi there, hoping you might be able to help. I'm looking at two bikes:
>a 2004 Giant TCR (not the composite model), and a 2004 Orbea

My personal experience with Orbea has been satisfactory. Nothing outstanding
but OK.
I have one in France. I also know of two other people who purchased an Orbea
bike in the same bike shop and both had a bad experience with their frame (it
simply broke after a few rides in both cases).
Granted this was not on the model you reference. In both cases the Bike Shop
guy replaced the carbon frames with no questions asked (obvious manufactoring
defect). Their aluminium weld jobs are a not very tidy, but that is mostly
esthetics. Don't know about their steel frames though. Steel + Carbon fork
ought to give you a comfortable ride though.

- Chris -
[Only registered and activated users can see links. ]
Sport Vacations
(Multisport, Cycling, Marathons, etc...)

12-12-2003, 02:38 PM

On 12 Dec 2003 07:28:43 -0800, [Only registered and activated users can see links. ] (Reenie)
wrote:
>Hi there, hoping you might be able to help. I'm looking at two bikes:
>a 2004 Giant TCR (not the composite model), and a 2004 Orbea
>Marmolada. Does anyone have any experience with any of these bikes
>(including older version!) - or these brands?

Which TCR?

I have a 2001 TCR2. I love it. It's a great bike. However, it's
entirely too aggressive in it's geometry and componentry for
non-racing use -- I changed out the stem for a 45 degree rise, 130mm
stem, and now I'm pretty happy with the fit. I continue to wish for
a triple whenever I find a long or steep hill.

The Obrea Marmolada looks similarly aggressive. It has nearly the
same gearing range as my TCR2 came with (although the TCR2 was
available in a triple, which I should have gotten). They seem very
similar, except frame material (TCR is Al, Marm is steel) and
component manufacturer (TCR has Shimano, Marm has Campy).

If you're going to be racing, or are very lightweight and flexible,
then either of those bikes ought to be great for you. Else,
consider something a little less aggressive.

>Thanks.
>Reenie
--
Rick Onanian

12-13-2003, 01:48 AM

Thanks for all of the replies.

At the moment I ride a steel Bianchi which is a very comfortable ride
- so I'm looking for something slightly more aggressive. While I very
much like the look of the Orbea - I've heard a few things about the
fragility of their frames already (which has been repeated here).

Also - while my local bike guy is willing to order me an Orbea (there
are no local dealers and I want to go to a local shop) he does deal in
Giants. So I think I will go for the TCR - which is also slightly less
expensive than the Orbea. I took a look at the TCR yesterday and was
very impressed, there seems to be a few upgrades from the 2003 model.
SO I think that settles it!

Thanks, again.

Reenie

Rick Onanian <[Only registered and activated users can see links. ]> wrote in message news:<[Only registered and activated users can see links. ]>. ..
> On 12 Dec 2003 07:28:43 -0800, [Only registered and activated users can see links. ] (Reenie)
> wrote:
> >Hi there, hoping you might be able to help. I'm looking at two bikes:
> >a 2004 Giant TCR (not the composite model), and a 2004 Orbea
> >Marmolada. Does anyone have any experience with any of these bikes
> >(including older version!) - or these brands?
>
> Which TCR?
>
> I have a 2001 TCR2. I love it. It's a great bike. However, it's
> entirely too aggressive in it's geometry and componentry for
> non-racing use -- I changed out the stem for a 45 degree rise, 130mm
> stem, and now I'm pretty happy with the fit. I continue to wish for
> a triple whenever I find a long or steep hill.
>
> The Obrea Marmolada looks similarly aggressive. It has nearly the
> same gearing range as my TCR2 came with (although the TCR2 was
> available in a triple, which I should have gotten). They seem very
> similar, except frame material (TCR is Al, Marm is steel) and
> component manufacturer (TCR has Shimano, Marm has Campy).
>
> If you're going to be racing, or are very lightweight and flexible,
> then either of those bikes ought to be great for you. Else,
> consider something a little less aggressive.
>
> >Thanks.
> >Reenie

12-13-2003, 01:51 AM

Hi Rick,

It's the 2004 TCR alloy:

[Only registered and activated users can see links. ]

(hope the link works!)

R

Rick Onanian <[Only registered and activated users can see links. ]> wrote in message

news:<[Only registered and activated users can see links. ]>. ..
> On 12 Dec 2003 07:28:43 -0800, [Only registered and activated users can see links. ] (Reenie)
> wrote:
> >Hi there, hoping you might be able to help. I'm looking at two bikes:
> >a 2004 Giant TCR (not the composite model), and a 2004 Orbea
> >Marmolada. Does anyone have any experience with any of these bikes
> >(including older version!) - or these brands?
>
> Which TCR?
>
> I have a 2001 TCR2. I love it. It's a great bike. However, it's
> entirely too aggressive in it's geometry and componentry for
> non-racing use -- I changed out the stem for a 45 degree rise, 130mm
> stem, and now I'm pretty happy with the fit. I continue to wish for
> a triple whenever I find a long or steep hill.
>
> The Obrea Marmolada looks similarly aggressive. It has nearly the
> same gearing range as my TCR2 came with (although the TCR2 was
> available in a triple, which I should have gotten). They seem very
> similar, except frame material (TCR is Al, Marm is steel) and
> component manufacturer (TCR has Shimano, Marm has Campy).
>
> If you're going to be racing, or are very lightweight and flexible,
> then either of those bikes ought to be great for you. Else,
> consider something a little less aggressive.
>
> >Thanks.
> >Reenie

12-13-2003, 06:50 PM

I have an Orbea (2002) Altec 2 setup, and I love it -- alum. frame,
carbon fork, full Ultegra. I had read some reviews on Orbea in Bicycling
(a USA periodical) and did some research. You get quality materials,
great construction, and a zippy ride. Have not ridden any Giants, but
would have bought the Orbea anyway, since it's unique. Plus, the "no-
stickers" paint job is really very nice (all logos and designs are
painted on). I'm not a hardcore racer, but I love to ride, and I love
the responsiveness and feel of my bike.

Plus, did you see Iban Mayo crank up the Alp d' Huez on an Orbea in this
year's Tour? It was beautiful.

--

12-14-2003, 03:37 AM

I have to confess that seeing Mayo zip up on the Orbea was inspiring,
and perhaps the reason I was considering the Orbea... and it is indeed
a beautiful bike. So I decided that when I return to live in Europe
I'll be getting that Orbea! Indeed my parents live in Spain and I
understand the Orbeas are less expensive there...

> I have an Orbea (2002) Altec 2 setup, and I love it -- alum. frame,
> carbon fork, full Ultegra. I had read some reviews on Orbea in Bicycling
> (a USA periodical) and did some research. You get quality materials,
> great construction, and a zippy ride. Have not ridden any Giants, but
> would have bought the Orbea anyway, since it's unique. Plus, the "no-
> stickers" paint job is really very nice (all logos and designs are
> painted on). I'm not a hardcore racer, but I love to ride, and I love
> the responsiveness and feel of my bike.
>
> Plus, did you see Iban Mayo crank up the Alp d' Huez on an Orbea in this
> year's Tour? It was beautiful.
>
>
>
> --

12-15-2003, 07:48 AM

Excellent! Another convert to the church of Orbea!

Enjoy the stellar European riding.

Regards, James

--